As we move forward with the beta, we'll write up some posts on X-Plane 11.10's the new features - there are a lot of them, to the point where I've lost track of what's actually in the release. Right now we're in the "does it work" phase, trying to get a beta that works for everyone without crashing. (Beta 1 worked fine for everyone in the company, but often our internal machines are very similar to each other, so early betas catch things we missed.)
So what follows is a big pile of nerdy stuff...I'm going to add random images in to make the post less boring. So picture is not related.
Where Do The Bugs Go
When you file a bug with our bug report form, it goes to a shared email in-box that someone triages - usually it's Jennifer, but sometimes it's me or Philipp. The person triaging the bug will then forward it to our internal bug tracking system (that's where those XPD-123 numbers come from) or possibly forward it to tech support - we do get a lot of "my sim is broken, help!" in the bug reporter.
This is why I always jump up and down and go "file a bug!": everything in the bug reporter gets looked at, and everything that is then filed is permanently tracked. At the end of 11.10 we can check the bug list and see what hasn't been fixed. Like all software, not all bugs will be fixed by the end of 11.10, but if the bug is tracked, this avoids us losing the bug.
Here are some ways to report a bug that are not tracked and are extremely likely to get lost:
- Posting in the blog comments section. We do not 'scrape' the blog for bug reports. If you write a blog comment and do nothing else, your bug will not be fixed.
- "Reporting" the bug on a public forum (x-plane.org, reddit, etc.). We don't scrape those either, so it's quite possible no one will see it.
- Emailing an engineer at Laminar Research directly.
The problem with direct email is that it doesn't go through the tracking system, you might not get the right engineer, and again, you're bypassing the mechanisms we have in place to not lose things. If you email someone organized and responsible like Tyler, he might file the bug for you. If you email someone like me, whose in-box looks like a grenade went off, there's a very good chance I lose your report.
Jennifer tries really hard to list every item that is fixed in each beta, so that you can tell when your issue is fixed and it's worth re-testing/re-reporting.
This system is far from perfect, and the number one request we get which is reasonable is better linkage between the internal tracking and the user reporting. I sympathize because we have the same problem of "it's a black box" with the technology vendors we depend on (Apple, Microsoft, Intel, AMD, NVidia).
Changing How We Build
With X-Plane 11.10 we moved to cmake for our build system. Previously we would maintain separate project files for all three operating systems. That's about 3x the amount of work it should be, so for 11.10, Sidney and Jörg moved us to cmake, which lets us manage X-Plane as a project once.
The down-side is that there have been a number of serious one-time bugs due to projection configuration problems, since using cmake meant rewriting all of the configuration info for building X-Plane. This is what caused the Linux bug in beta 1 that we required libc++ (fixed during 11.00's beta process, it popped back up when we replaced makefiles) as well as a number of other random bugs we fixed before public beta started.
In the long term cmake is a win - having gone through the pain of the migration, it's just quicker for us to administer X-Plane's project files, which means more coding and less fighting with X-Code, MSVC, etc.
In the last few months we've automated our build and our packaging process, as well as the amount of testing done automatically by the build system. Hopefully this will turn into bugs being caught earlier, and it makes it easier to cut new betas - getting quick betas out to fix crash bugs wasn't time consuming. I expect the beta count to be higher for 11.10 than in the past due to the lower cost of recutting the build.
(If I had to cut five betas in a week for 11.05 I'd be pretty cranky at everyone - five betas in a week is totally doable now.)
Graphics Cards That Remember
Before X-Plane 11.10, X-Plane would set up shading for a given material by telling the graphics card about every aspect of the material. Over and over. Every time the material was used. For every single frame. For every single view in the frame.
X-Plane 11.10 now stores parts of the materials in VRAM, so they can be referred to as needed. This is part of our restructuring of the rendering engine for VR, Metal and Vulkan.
This was also the cause of the "invalid UBO" errors in beta 1 - now that we are saving materials and not just reiterating them per frame, we have to get the book keeping right. Sidney set the sim up to crash if the book keeping is done wrong. (This is a good thing - the sim is going to crash anyways if the book keeping is wrong -- at least this way the auto-report explains exactly what happened, rather than us having to autopsy the resulting carnage and squint to find the root cause.)
AMD Users: this code is not working on AMD cards right now, which means you aren't seeing some performance improvements. We're working this week to see if we can get this going on AMD cards too - stay tuned.